Readers of my blog will note that my last posts on Estonia were in September. My mood was euphoric in both and indeed, my Tallinn experience was all in all, a happy one. Yet, I admit I wasn’t always happy. I missed my family, my friends and I missed Soumyadip and wished he were there to share my excitement at finding myself in such a fresh, green, coniferous and peaceful, new land. I wanted to run and dance and hop, under the pines, scrunching cones and needles and silver birch twigs under my feet and doing my best not to slip on the mossy green undergrowth. It was hard to be so ecstatic and yet alone. Being alone when you’re miserable can be dealt with and is sometimes desirable but when you’re happy, you need someone to share it with.
Luckily for Skype.
Did you know that peer to peer sharing was invented in Tallinn?
Nonetheless, this blog post, ‘Tallinn Diaries Part III’ is a continuation of my Tallinn series but unlike the others, it is written in hindsight and is thus, retrospective rather than euphoric.
Now that I’m back in Delhi, sitting on my parents’ couch and mentally groaning while being lectured on the many things I still have to learn, I think back to what I used to call my ‘hospital bed room’ in the Academic Hostel at Akadeemia tee, Tallinn. I had never made much effort in trying to make it home unlike my Godavari Hostel room in JNU. I realise now that it was because I was sure, deep within, that it was “only three months” and I wasn’t there to stay. And that gets me wondering- how would I have behaved if I were?
I’d have gotten a job, earned a scanty wage, paid through my nose for essentials but guzzled cheap alcohol and wished I could have afforded to live in a Nordic country –much like how I live in Delhi except that here, I pay through my nose for alcohol as well.
How is Estonia as a place to live? It’s beautiful and serene. It’s a lovely place to think and work. But the pay is low, the unemployment is high and the government has never floated a single bond. I was shocked to see a white man foraging in a bin for food. It shouldn’t have surprised me as the poor in my own country are absolutely destitute. People die of cold in Delhi every winter without having the middle class person bat an eyelid. But this was the first time I had seen a white man reduced to this and I realised that poverty is demeaning and pathetic anywhere.
Nonetheless, the government never floats a single bond, frightened for its dear life of sovereign debt. Is this a price to pay for not turning into ‘another Greece’? When the crisis came, Estonia took advantage of its reduction in inflation to join the Eurozone. It seems odd for an outsider, but to an Estonian policy maker, this decision was taken long ago and this was simply a window of opportunity. So while other governments were following countercyclical policies, the Estonian government was quite happy with the cyclical change. (I should cite Darrell’s paper here.)
National pride is important to the Estonians. They would like to be a developed country. And joining the Eurozone was a very expensive membership to a very exclusive club. A fixed exchange rate peg couldn’t be maintained very long in the face of capital flows anyway. Not that capital flows were any easier to deal with once the euro came.
Being in the EU, hasn’t helped all that much. For one thing, Estonian manufacturing doesn’t have the level of competitiveness required in Europe and unable to devalue, Estonia has seen subtle but noticeable deindustrialisation. Unemployment has also been exacerbated by the rise of foreign owned retail chains which have wiped out the old, specialised little shops. Yes, Estonia has a lot to teach India in this regard.
Nevertheless, Estonia is the better off amongst the Baltic States. Riga in Latvia saw bank runs while I was in Tallinn. In fact the joke in Latvia was that in Riga, it is the banks that fall, in Tallinn, it is only the Christmas Tree. (The Tallinn Christmas Tree did fall over three times after it had been set up.) Beggars hung about outside one of Riga’s churches. The Latvian ‘lati’ is valued even higher than the euro, at a fixed exchange rate, and is in desperate need for a devaluation.
Yes, the Baltics were a pessimistic economist’s paradise. Nonetheless, for me, coming as I do from the Third World, any quiet place with stellar infrastructure is lovely and I wish India could have had the Estonian infrastructure –the trolleys, the libraries from which books could be found and issued in less than five minutes, bank accounts that took no more than fifteen minutes to operate, traffic that stopped for pedestrians (Oh! How wonderful!) More than anything else, I felt I was getting spoilt- three months of blissful peace with no honking cars and scooters. Better still, Estonians have a firm respect for privacy and prefer sending emails and texts to making calls even though calling in Estonia is pretty cheap. So no crazy phone ringing. Ah!
Until...
I began to miss the noise. The best thing about being abroad is that you realise how wonderful home is. You miss the drive, the energy, the passion, the way so many people fight cheerfully every day –if only to survive, the warmth, the small fact that things can be repaired –that one shouldn’t waste ...you miss home. Delhi’s a terrible city but at the end of the day, it’s mine. And I missed it dearly.
And when it comes to where you’re going, it helps to know where you’re from. When an (I must admit) awfully good looking but immensely stupid young man told me I was the prettiest girl at xyz party, I explained to him, rather civilly, that I’m brown and I’m different so ofcourse, he likes me. He remained unconvinced for a while and then he realised I had a point. Either that, or I bored him stiff -because I didn’t hear from him again.
European men are as bad as what Mrs. Datta calls the ‘cheapus indicus’ or ‘The Great Indian Cheapie’. Well, they don’t get harass-y unless it’s at a pub. Somehow, the cheapus internationale seem to think women go to pubs to get harassed. Nonetheless, walking alone on the dark, scary streets isn’t much fun. (You get fined 40 euro if you aren’t wearing a ‘reflector’ for one.) Yes, men and women aren’t that different elsewhere in the world. I found I was more prudish about accepting compliments from drunken strangers than some of my Estonian acquaintances but that’s ok because it kept me alive. I was also a lot less bothered about and somewhat more comfortable with my personal appearance than most Estonian and western girls I met. That could be the effects of the burgeoning sex industry and the pressure it puts on young girls to look like the girls in the magazines.
What else? I liked the lack of hierarchy and I liked being able to call everyone by name. But I had a hard time explaining to Riaz that I would rather call my supervisor “Ma’am” than “Jayati” because there’s an awful lot of affection and respect that I throw into the word “Ma’am” especially, when I’m using it for my supervisor. I was lucky to participate in study Group discussions even though it never kicked off as such and I was really lucky to meet all of the people I met, some of whom, I still say, are beyond brilliant. I love the way their minds work. Conversations with Riaz were particularly exciting (and somewhat exhausting) as I got to revise my dialectics.
I realised that a nice, useful way of looking at the world is to put Economics first. It works to think of technological change driving changes in production relations and then changes in institutions and in society. And I learnt how to see this in non Marxist terms as well. I learnt to appreciate the heterodox movement in Economics- the communion of Marxists, Keynesians, Schumpeterians and well, anyone opposed to neo liberalism –to stand up against austerity Economics and to stand up for the interests of ordinary people. You may kick and fight but it’s important to be generous and to give in order to take. There’s so much that we have to teach and learn from each other! We might as well start.
Yes, I learnt a lot at Tallinn. It was more energy saving than Oslo where thanks to cheap oil, it is cheaper to live in the suburbs. It was post Soviet, well planned and charmingly medieval. It would have liked to be Nordic but to be Nordic, you need to do more than to give pedestrians the right of the way. You have to make your policies for the common man.